I don’t know what the rankings will be yet with all the upheaval, but I couldn’t help but be amused by some of the results over the weekend. It was a bad day to be a fan of a ranked team from Texas (I’ll mention the two big ones, but Houston and Baylor also lost), and it was a good day for Sun Belt teams to notch some historical road wins. (I only recently realized Marshall had joined the Sun Belt after previous stints in the MAC and CUSA.)
The grass was really looking greener to LSU fans who wanted Jimbo Fisher or Billy Napier, for instance. I think Notre Dame fans (even if they are genuine about having grown tired of Kelly) were insecure about their choice of Marcus Freeman, who had never been a head coach before; but their way of expressing it in most cases was to attack Brian Kelly any way they could and pretend to be overjoyed that he had been replaced.
Last week (last two sections in the link below), I wrote about reminding myself as an LSU fan not to take anything for granted. Wearing the jersey and helmet and playing in Tiger Stadium might all but guarantee you beat Southern, but it doesn’t guarantee you anything against an SEC schedule.
More on Nebraska
I also mentioned in a separate blog how unless you were Oklahoma, Nebraska was pretty much untouchable for most of the 1970s and 1980s. I think there is a lesson here for some of the LSU fans who are always unhappy with whomever the coach is.
I didn’t mention it because they didn’t play LSU after that, but the Huskers kept it going through the 90s (I found out they had the second-best record among FBS teams in the decade after Florida St.) and had some good teams in the early 2000s. After having two losing records (both on the recent end) from 1961 to 2014, the Huskers have only finished with a winning record once since then.
To get to their current situation, they just lost to Georgia Southern, who was playing in the Southern Conference of FCS 10 years ago. It wasn’t just one fluke loss either. The Huskers have now lost eight consecutive games against FBS opponents. The last such game that was a win was over Northwestern, 56-7. You would have thought that at least the Huskers could stay better than that team, but they lost to the Wildcats at a neutral site just a couple of weeks ago.
After I wrote the above, Nebraska decided to part ways with head coach Scott Frost. Mickey Joseph, who for whatever reason stayed loyal to Ed Orgeron and LSU from 2017 to 2021 as the wide receivers coach, will step in as the interim head coach. He was obviously not retained by Brian Kelly but was classy all the way. I wish him the absolute best of luck in that position. If he doesn’t end up being a head coach, I wouldn’t be surprised if he returned at some point.
Joseph is the sixth man to coach Nebraska (including interims) since Frank Solich was fired in 2003. Solich was the last coach to leave Nebraska after successfully avoiding a losing season for his tenure. Only two men (Bob Devaney and Tom Osborne) coached Nebraska over the 36 seasons before Solich was hired. There was another LSU connection as former Tigers defensive coordinator Bo Pelini was hired from Les Miles’s staff after the 2007 season. Let’s just say he experienced mixed reviews, but he has had far and away the best winning percentage and longest tenure since Solich left.
Another more indirect LSU connection: Solich employed Joe Burrow’s father Jimmy (whom he first hired as a graduate assistant at Nebraska) as defensive coordinator at Ohio from 2005 to 2018. Solich himself retired after the 2020 season.
Recent Comments by LSU and Notre Dame Fans
Speaking of Joe Burrow, 2018 and 2019 (which his father had retired to witness) had the best combined winning percentage (89.3) of any two back-to-back seasons in LSU history. Even though I think an average Power 5 head coach could have managed to go over .500 the next two seasons and Orgeron didn’t, it still looks bad that those great seasons only bought him two additional years. I don’t know who they think is coming to the rescue if they run Kelly out of town without a fair shot at building the program back up.
At least one of the notions they had got knocked down a peg this weekend when Jimbo and Texas A&M lost at home to Appalachian St., a program Les Miles beat easily (with probably his worst team) the year after they upset Michigan in 2007.
Freeman, we were told, had already begun to correct for Kelly’s various misdeeds in recruiting and game strategy even though he started 0-2. Well, Oklahoma St. (in the bowl last season) and Ohio St. (who beat the Irish in the opener) were certainly much better teams than Florida St. at least. That last sentence is true enough, but I’m not so sure you could say the same about Marshall.
The Jimbo crowd started going nuts last year when the Aggies knocked off Alabama (and LSU struggled in some early games) and then pretended the losses didn’t matter. I think I prefer the way things have been at LSU. When we beat Alabama, we’re going places that season. These are the wins over Alabama since Saban was hired and the season results:
- 2007, National Championship (12-2)
- 2010, won Cotton Bowl to finish 11-2
- 2011, National Runners-up (to Alabama, 13-1)
- 2019, National Championship (15-0)
Texas A&M did go 11-2 in 2012, also winning the Cotton Bowl, but didn’t even keep the Tide from winning the SEC West as LSU at least helped to do all four years above. Alabama finished fourth in the West in 2010, but they were still very much alive for a berth in the SEC title game (with wins over LSU and Auburn, to whom they would later lose by only a single point) when they visited Tiger Stadium that year.
Though I would take 8-4 before the bowl any kind of way this season, finishing 8-4 despite beating Alabama seems like a waste in your fourth year somewhere like A&M.
Kevin Sumlin, Jimbo’s predecessor, beat Alabama exactly once too. He had a slightly better record in his first 50 games than what Jimbo has after 50 games with the Aggies. This is despite the fact that Texas A&M has increased the head coach’s salary by about 50% since Sumlin left. Almost two years of additional salary was paid to Sumlin to go away. Jimbo’s most-recent extension takes him through 2031. This makes his contract very similar to the one Kelly has. Kelly makes $1 million more in base salary, but I’m not sure how the overall compensation compares. Regardless, I’ll be interested to see which head coach has more success over the next 10 seasons despite Jimbo’s four-year head start.
Good and Bad News from the SEC
Anyway, while in a way I’m disappointed that the SEC didn’t look nearly as good this week as it did in Week 1, I am somewhat encouraged by seeing some vulnerability in a few of the teams on LSU’s schedule in addition to Alabama (more on them later in the week) and Texas A&M:
- Tennessee needed overtime to beat Pitt, and that was against a backup QB who seemed like he was playing hurt after the starter had to leave the game.
- Kentucky beat Florida by 10 in the Swamp after the Gators failed to score an offensive point in the last 35 ½ minutes of the game. (Tennessee and Florida are LSU’s only two SEC East opponents.). Oh by the way, yet another contingent of LSU fans (they may overlap with some of the others) was angry that the Tigers didn’t hire Billy Napier, the former coach at UL-Lafayette and new coach at Florida.
- Auburn only beat San Jose St. by 8 points at home after trailing at halftime.
Interestingly, those five teams all had the same home/away status last week as they will against LSU. So hopefully Alabama and Tennessee continue to have trouble on the road and the others continue to struggle at home.
I’ll have more to say when I post the rankings later in the week.
Alabama, Appalachian St., Baylor, Cincinnati, College Football, College Football Playoff, Georgia, Houston, Iowa St., LSU, Michigan, Michigan St., Notre Dame, Ohio St., Oklahoma, Oklahoma St., Oregon, San Diego St., TCU, top 25, UL-Lafayette, Utah, Utah St., UTSA, Wake Forest
Brian Kelly Timeline and New Rankings
In Bowls, College Football, College Football Playoff, General LSU, Rankings, Rankings Commentary on December 5, 2021 at 3:10 PMBrian Kelly Timeline
In the last blog, I decided not to speculate on some aspects of how the deal that brought Kelly to LSU materialized (through his agent) when and how it did. I’m glad that I didn’t because more information has come out. It’s not completely different from what I thought, but the picture is more complete now.
Brian Kelly made an interesting comment to Rece Davis in an interview on GameDay. He said that his agent Trace Armstrong told him about several inquiries that he had received; but he only discussed this at the end of the season. Unless his agent called his wife and cleared it with her first, I don’t think he meant the very end of the season. I suspect that he wasn’t so overwhelmed with the stress of Notre Dame’s looming game against 3-8 Stanford that he took a little bit of time to have conversations with his agent and his family during the week prior to that game. It is plausible that the only direct conversation with Woodward was after the Stanford game though, and it makes sense that everything had to become settled relatively quickly. My conclusion about Kelly having some prior conversations is also supported by LSU grad Booger McFarland, who said the deal with Kelly (or at least the formal offer) was already on the verge of being finalized on Saturday.
I think Armstrong knew Kelly and Woodward were keeping quiet, so he had the opportunity to fill the void by suggesting the job was actually going to Riley. Riley was probably going to USC at that point anyway, but Armstrong was able to get a more favorable contract approved more quickly than he would have otherwise. It didn’t hurt Kelly that he was able to stay under the radar as long as he did. Whether Riley’s name floating around helped Woodward to secure the funding I’m not sure. Some have speculated that Woodward knew a long time ago, perhaps before even taking the job or at least before the Orgeron announcement, the money was going to be in place.
I imagine someone at LSU other than Scott Woodward had to be apprised of the situation to finalize the deal even though Woodward was given broad latitude. At that point a leak was inevitable. Any major news about LSU football gets all over town very quickly. I’m not saying the leak was out of malice. It might have just been to calm down some of the hysteria regarding Riley going to another team. Some worried that Riley was the guy Woodward was counting on all this time and that he didn’t have a backup plan.
There was an article by former LSU beat writer Ross Dellenger, who now works for Sports Illustrated. It says that Woodward made one last phone call to Jimbo Fisher prior to the weekend before proceeding with hiring Kelly. I hope that isn’t true; but if it is, I’m glad Jimbo said no. I know Woodward likes to hire champions, but Fisher left Florida St. as it was going down the tubes in the years after his national title there. I certainly think his is an improvement over the previous coaching staff in College Station, but you don’t pay someone a salary like that to go 8-4. I’m not certain Kelly will do better, but I’d rather have the uncertainty than the knowledge of what Jimbo has done in recent years. If he were available, I think it would have cost a lot more than the Kelly deal did anyway.
Ratings and Playoff Commentary
I mentioned last week that Alabama did not schedule well out of conference; but the Tide played 6 games against SEC West opponents, all of whom were bowl-eligible and which included #9 Ole Miss, as well as otherwise-undefeated Georgia and 7-5 Tennessee.
I explained last week that Oklahoma St. had a very good schedule, and it was even better than Alabama’s. This is why the Cowboys are ranked higher than Notre Dame despite the additional loss. To illustrate this point, Virginia and West Virginia are both 6-6 with almost identical strengths of schedule. Notre Dame beat Virginia, while Oklahoma St. beat West Virginia. Notre Dame only beat two teams that were better: Purdue and Wisconsin. Oklahoma St. beat four teams that were better: Boise St., Kansas St., Baylor, and Oklahoma. Both teams won 2/3 of their games against better teams, but being tested more often should give Oklahoma St. the edge. Even if we expand it to the top 80 (we are still talking about risky opponents here—#76 TCU beat Baylor, #77 Illinois beat two ranked teams on the road, and #70 Florida was a field goal away from beating Alabama), Oklahoma St. still played almost twice as many in that range.
Baylor does belong lower than Notre Dame though. Although BYU was a good non-conference opponent, the Bears scheduled Texas St. (who went 4-8 and is my #111) and Texas Southern (who only beat two other FCS opponents). Although they essentially played the game conference schedule as Oklahoma St. did, losing to bad teams is punished a little more harshly. As mentioned, TCU is #76. Iowa St., who beat Oklahoma St., is #49.
All three are relatively close though. There is more than twice as much separation between #4 Cincinnati and #5 Oklahoma St. than there is between #5 Oklahoma St. and #7 Baylor. There is just under twice as much space between #7 Baylor and #8 Ohio St.
There is a consensus about who the four semifinal teams should be and since the focus of my ratings is creating a fair objective top four, I could not be more satisfied. You can quibble about how high UL-Lafayette and UT-San Antonio are—I think teams like Michigan St., Oklahoma, and Utah would beat both easily—but I don’t mind giving credit to successful seasons. Even with an expanded playoff, I wouldn’t want teams with more than one or two losses this season in it, so I don’t mind if 1-loss ULL or 1-loss UTSA are higher than teams who would be highly favored to beat them.
I also think if Cincinnati played number 5 through 10 they’d be lucky to win one or two. On the other hand, the Bearcats are 1-0 against that group; and a lot of people would have told you out of 10 tries Oregon would beat Utah 9 or 10 of them. If you missed it, the Ducks had two shots at the Utes and fell far short both times. Anyway, I also don’t think a two-loss non-champion would be more deserving of a slot in the top 4 even if they look better to me. Oklahoma St. and others had their chances and fell short. About a foot short in the case of Oklahoma St. against Baylor. The best Cowboy teams always lose to Iowa St. though. This also happened 10 years ago when the Cowboys missed the top two in favor of the Tide.
Houston stayed close with Cincinnati for a while, so I don’t love the fact that they fell out of the top 25; but Utah St. deserved to move back into it after their solid win over San Diego St. for the Mountain West title. I like seeing some stability as far as which teams are in the top 25. In the last three weeks, only four teams have fallen out. Utah St. was one of those four, so there are only three different teams than there were three weeks ago.
Championship losers San Diego St., Appalachian St., and Wake Forest all managed to stay in the top 25. There needs to be a penalty for losing; but just like I’m glad Oklahoma St. didn’t fall out of the top 5 in favor of Notre Dame, I like that it’s not so harsh that any of the three fell below enough idle teams to fall out of the top 25.
I wrote everything above last night, but I just wanted to respond briefly to Michigan being placed ahead of Georgia. It doesn’t really matter who #2 and #3 are, but it’s the only difference between the respective top fours, so I wanted to address it.
Georgia Tech isn’t even in that top 80 group I was talking about, but the Bulldogs are in luck because that’s the third-best team they scheduled out of conference. I have Clemson just outside of the top 25 and UAB at #50. Of course they avoided Alabama and Ole Miss in the regular season. Imagine the arguments if they had played Alabama. Anyway, Arkansas and Auburn as the non-divisional games still aren’t bad. Michigan’s Big Ten schedule did include some bad teams though. Rutgers, Nebraska, Northwestern, and Indiana all have losing records compared to just one in-conference opponent for Georgia that had a losing record. Michigan’s one Power Five opponent rates worse than Georgia Tech. MAC champion Northern Illinois was a help and Western Michigan rated similarly to UAB, but it should not be enough to put them ahead.
That said, if the committee made the decision based on the team that will take the field at the end of the month being harder to beat rather than resume, I do agree with Michigan being ahead. They finished very strong. If they play the way they played against Ohio St. and Iowa, they can beat anyone. If Georgia plays the way they played against Alabama, especially with the turnovers, they won’t have much of a chance.
Top 25
Out of Rankings: (23) Houston
1-130 computer ratings